Cinquefoils of the Black Hills
All 7 cinquefoils in this guide, side by side, A to Z. Compare the photos, bloom time, height and where each grows, then open the one that fits for more photos and the full ID notes. Each plant's page lists its sources.
| Plant | Color | Blooms | Height | Where | How to tell it apart |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Early CinquefoilPotentilla concinna | Yellow | Spring to early summer | 2–16 cm (1–6 in) | Mixed grass prairie, open forests and woodlands, at mid to high elevations | Look for a low tuft of mostly basal leaves, each with usually 5 narrow, toothed leaflets spreading from one point, gray to white and cottony underneath and often curled. Pennsylvania cinquefoil, by contrast, stands upright and has leaflets set along a central stalk. |
Leafy CinquefoilDrymocallis fissa | Yellow | May into August | 12–45 cm (5–18 in) | Open forests, sagebrush slopes and stream banks; often rocky or disturbed ground | Look for wide-open flowers with overlapping yellow petals 7–11 mm long, large elongated anthers, and leaves with 4 to 6 or more pairs of toothed leaflets, often with smaller ones between. Tall Cinquefoil has white to creamy petals, tightly packed clusters, and stems 30–90 cm (1–3 ft) tall. |
Shrubby CinquefoilDasiphora fruticosa | Yellow | June into August | 20–100 cm (8–39 in) | Hillsides, meadows, canyons and exposed ridges; open, sunny sites | Look for a woody, bushy plant with shredding reddish bark on older stems. Leaves have 3 to 7 narrow, smooth-edged leaflets 10–20 mm long, with scattered white hairs above and denser gray hairs beneath. Yellow petals are 6–13 mm long, on single flowers or small clusters. |
SilverweedArgentina anserina | Yellow | June into September | 5–20 cm (2–8 in), with runners up to 90 cm (3 ft) long | Wet meadows, stream and creek banks, floodplains and muddy shores | Look for a low, creeping plant that spreads by thin red runners, 30–90 cm (1–3 ft) long, with a cluster of leaves and a flower stalk coming up from some of the nodes. Each leaf is divided into 7 or more sharply toothed leaflets with smaller leaflets between them, and the underside of the leaf is silvery from long white hairs. The flower is yellow, about 2 cm (¾ in) across, with 5 rounded petals, and sits alone at the end of a bare stalk 2.5–15 cm (1–6 in) long, usually separate from the leaves, so it can look as if it grows straight from the ground. |
Slender CinquefoilPotentilla gracilis | Yellow | June into August | 20–80 cm (8–31 in) | Moist meadows, open woods and stream banks | Look for hand-shaped leaves with 5 to 9 narrow, sharply toothed leaflets, green above and silky white beneath, and loose clusters of 3 or more golden yellow flowers. Sulfur Cinquefoil, an introduced plant with its own page in this guide, has light yellow petals and green leaf undersides. |
Sulphur CinquefoilPotentilla recta | Yellow | June into August | 20–80 cm (8–30 in) | Roadsides, pastures, old fields, grassland and open forest | Look for pale, sulphur-yellow flowers 1.5–2.5 cm (½–1 in) across with 5 petals notched at the tip and a brighter yellow patch at the base of each, held in branched, flat-topped clusters at the top of the stem. The stems stand upright, branch only near the top, and are covered in long, stiff, spreading hairs over a layer of short hairs. The leaves are hand-shaped, with 5 to 7 coarsely toothed, hairy leaflets spreading from one point and the middle leaflet longest, and they continue up the stem, while the leaves at the base are short-lived. After the petals fall, the sepals fold up into a cup around the seeds. Slender Cinquefoil, the native plant it is most often confused with, has brighter yellow flowers, mostly basal leaves with few on the stem, and short hairs on the stem and leaf stalks instead of long ones standing straight out. Tall Cinquefoil has white flowers and leaflets set along a central stalk rather than spreading from one point. |
Tall CinquefoilDrymocallis arguta | White | June into August | 30–90 cm (12–35 in) | Prairies, open woods, woodland edges and roadsides | Look for creamy-white flowers, 1.3–2 cm across, packed in tight clusters with only a few open at a time, sharp green sepals about as long as the petals, and sticky-hairy stems. Most leaves grow near the base, with 7 to 11 toothed leaflets. Leafy Cinquefoil has yellow petals, flowers that open wide, and shorter stems, mostly 15–35 cm. |
Other look-alike groups: 38 groups
- Anemones (4)
- Asters (4)
- Beardtongues (5)
- Buttercups (3)
- Cacti (4)
- Clovers (6)
- Coneflowers (4)
- Currants and gooseberries (5)
- Daisies (5)
- Dandelions (3)
- Docks and buckwheats (4)
- Evening primroses (4)
- Ferns (4)
- Gentians (4)
- Grasses (11)
- Groundsels and ragworts (3)
- Lilies (5)
- Mayflowers and false Solomon's seals (3)
- Milkvetches and locoweeds (12)
- Milkweeds (6)
- Mints (8)
- Mustards (11)
- Orchids (8)
- Paintbrushes (3)
- Pines (3)
- Raspberries and thimbleberries (3)
- Sagebrushes and sageworts (3)
- Sedges (3)
- Speedwells and kittentails (3)
- Sunflowers (4)
- Thistles (6)
- Vervains (3)
- Vetches (4)
- Violets (7)
- Wild lettuces (3)
- Wild onions (3)
- Wild plums and cherries (3)
- Willows (3)






